As I already stated they can do whatever they want in terms of their guild requirements . It's just going to cripple them. This isn't an FPS like GTA represents. Many of the players we've ran with at the 60 level dungeon diving aren't into cod or bf and to set a strict requirement like that on a guild for a game we don't support isn't going to make for easy growth which u will need to be able to compete in end game.
Sounds to me more like Breaks complained about something, as you're not in the guild so u couldn't see it and he's the ONLY member that left.
Either way there's. no point arguing or discussing the 2 guilds as I know we won't be leaving to join that one.
We preach this family thing and yet Breaks didn't even give it consideration to discuss the verbage of the guild info etc before taking this route. Is what it is but as this game is not supported by CAG I will jot be leaving the guild already established to join this new one and I'm pretty sure a majority of the ppl that play with us won't either but I don't speak for them.
So best of luck to breaks etc